Why Shared Leads Close at Ten Percent
A shared lead is a customer request sent to multiple service providers at the same time. Platforms such as Angi, Thumbtack, and HomeAdvisor typically send each request to three to five contractors, and each contractor pays for the opportunity to bid. The customer receives multiple quotes within hours, often before they've finished describing the job to the first responder.
The math is straightforward: if a lead goes to four contractors and all four are equally qualified, each has a 25% theoretical maximum close rate before accounting for price, availability, or rapport. In practice, close rates on shared leads fall between 5% and 15% because customers often choose the lowest bid, ghost after collecting quotes, or were never serious buyers. A 10% close rate on shared leads is typical, not a sign that your sales process is broken.
- Shared leads are sold to three to five contractors simultaneously
- Each contractor pays whether they win the job or not
- Close rates of 5-15% reflect competition, not just sales skill


